If Witch, Then Which? has enough adorable moments to make this a decent romcom, and its final volume doesn't end up as a rushed hack job.
Sep 17, 2021 • Subscribe
More like this
If Witch, Then Which? Volume 2 Review
If Witch, Then Which? Volume 2's humor picks up sharply, but an abrupt tone change hampers an otherwise hilarious series.
The Anti-Social Geniuses Review: If Witch, Then Which? Volume 1
The Anti-Social Geniuses review Ato Sakurai's If Witch, Then Which?, which appears it'll be a pretty ridiculous gender bender manga!
Witch Hat Atelier Volume 3 Review
Happy 7th Anniversary, Witch Hat Atelier!
Stellar Witch LIP☆S Volume 3 Review
Stellar Witch LIP☆S continues to be visually impressive, but the lack of high-stakes moments continue to be a detriment to the series.
Which Gundam? Witch Gundam
This is symbolism, right?
Mobile Suit Gundam, Mobile Suit Gundam: The Witch from Mercury
Wandering Witch: The Journey of Elaina Volume 3 Review
With neat paneling, visuals, and better chosen stories from the light novel, there's much to look forward to as Wandering Witch continues.
Flying Witch Volume 9 Review
The mandrakes view Makoto as what? And Chinatsu freaks out after learning what at the festival? There's much to explore in Flying Witch Volume 9!
Flying Witch Volume 8 Review
Makoto ventures to learn what type of element she is; Anzu runs into a samurai ghost; and zombies and volleyball somehow mix in Vol. 8 of Flying Witch!
Disclosure 131 - Which Witch? (9/17/2024)
We'll be watching out for this one
Witch Hat Atelier Volume 5 Review
The end of the trial arc! What will become of Euini and the apprentices?
Witch Hat Atelier Volume 4 Review
I didn’t expect that the volume would end like that!
Witch Hat Atelier, Vol. 3 Review
I'm still reading Kamome Shirahama's manga series! Here are my thoughts on the third volume.
Stellar Witch LIP☆S Volume 2 Review
Stellar Witch LIP☆S volume 2 proves it's solely for magical girl manga fans due to all the conventional storylines in the read.
Witch Hat Atelier Volume 1 – Manga Review
Published by Kodansha Comics, Kamome Shirahama’s Witch Hat Atelier stars one Coco, a young girl with a fascination for the magic that exists within her world. Unfortunately for…
Stellar Witch LIP☆S Volume 1 Review
What do you get when you cross Sailor Moon with St. Tail? Stellar Witch LIP☆S. That may or may not be a good thing depending on what you're…
Stellar Witch LIP☆S Volume 4 Review
While the previous volume felt like a bit of a stall tactic, volume 4 returns to moving the story forward -- on an individual level.
Stellar Witch LIP☆S Volume 5 Review
While it has its strengths over the classics Stellar Witch LIP☆S just doesn't have enough time to be a stellar example of this genre.
Which is Witch? Mary and the Witch's Wish-List
Blog about anime and manga
Needless, The Secret World of Arrietty, When Marnie Was There
This Week in Anime - Which Anime Witch Is This?
Chris and Steve put on their pointy hats and hop on their brooms to magic up some witchy anime.
If I Could Reach You Volume 6 (Manga Review)
Review of "If I Could Reach You" manga volume 6 by tMnR
If We Leave on the Dot Volume 1 Review
With cute art and a moving story between two co-workers, there's a lot to enjoy and like in If We Leave on the Dot.
Pandora Hearts Volume 3 Review
The volume where everyone’s got issues.
Tearmoon Empire Volume 3 Review
While Tearmoon Empire was originally conceived as a one arc story, Volume 3 maintains a lot of the same fun from the first two volumes.
Mieruko-chan Volume 3 Review
Miko has a brand new problem that's affecting her friend, which means she can't avoid the terrifying spirits in Volume 3 of Mieruko-chan.
Harukana Receive Volume 3 Review
Kanata and Narumi's past is further explored in Volume 3 of Harukana Receive, but don't think we aren't introduced to a child commercial star in this one!
Vampire Dormitory Volume 3 Review
Title: Vampire DormitoryGenre: Gender bender, romance, supernaturalPublisher: Kodansha (JP), Kodansha Comics (US)Creator: Ema ToyamaSerialized in: NakayoshiLocalization Staff: Devon Corwin (Translator), Noelle Yamagami (Letterer), Sarah Tilson (Editor)Original Release Date:…
Thunder 3 Volume 1 Review
Thunder 3 surprises the readers with an intriguing story with endearing characters and interesting art.
Eniale & Dewiela Volume 3 Review
From fun fights, bawdy comedy, and lots of great fashion designs, Eniale & Dewiela has been a delightful read from start to finish.
Prince Freya Volume 3 Review
Freya knows that despite the odds she must stop the Sigurd army in Prince Freya Volume 3, but its story execution leaves a lot to be desired.
Cat + Gamer Volume 3 Review
Cat + Gamer Volume 3 depicts a relatable work-life dilemma -- Riko tries to plan gaming time, but Musubi simply doesn't care!
Summertime Rendering Volume 3 Review
Going through a recording Ushio left behind, and viewing Ushioh’s (shadow replacement) memories like a video, Shinpei and Sou see how far the current tragedy on Hitogashima has…
The Dawn of the Witch Volume 1 Review
If you're a manga reader who likes fantasy, the semi-sequel to Grimoire of Zero, The Dawn of the Witch, isn't likely to impress you.
Anibros Podcast Episode 35 – If Nothing Works Then You Have to Scream
This week, along with the usual anime chatter that you know and love, we bring you a review of Giant Robo the Animation:…
Thoughts on Wandering Witch: The Journey of Elaina Volume 3 (Manga)
Itsuki Nanao continues to chronicle Elaina’s adventures in manga form with the third volume of Wandering Witch: The Journey of Elaina. This particular set of tales sees her…
Burn the Witch Chapter 3: Recap and Review
Chapter 3 of Burn the Witch opens with Billy Banx Jr. leering outside of the Top of Horns meeting room. He's confronted by Sullivan Squire.
I Don’t Know Which Is Love Volume 1
Soraike Mei, on the day of her high school graduation, had her heart broken by the girl she’d had a crush on for three years. In college then,…
I Don’t Know Which Is Love, Volume 2
by Luce, Staff Writer Welcome back to the rollercoaster Yuri harem series, I Don’t Know Which Is Love, Volume 2. Our protagonist is Mei Soraike, a girl who…
Wandering Witch: The Journey of Elaina Volume 2 Review
Many stories like The Journey of Elaina feature a variety of characters, but we haven't met anyone that's definitely "a good person".
Wandering Witch: The Journey of Elaina Volume 2 Review
TheOASG reviews Volume 2 of Wandering Witch, where Elaina's journey across the world might be best told in manga form.
Hi Score Girl Volume 3 Review
The level of gaming between Haruo and Akira intensifies in Volume 3 of Hi Score Girl...but it's at a point where Haruo begins growing up?
Sex Ed 120% Volume 3 Review
While it's worth reading from an educational standpoint, Sex Ed 120%'s varied tales make it worth reading even as a manga fan.
My Happy Marriage Volume 3 Review
With family politics and more of the supernatural aspects explained, this is the volume where My Happy Marriage truly becomes a series.
The Golden Sheep Volume 3 Review
Title: The Golden Sheep (Kin no Hitsugi)Genre: Drama, Coming of AgePublisher: Kodansha (JP), Vertical (US)Serialized in: AfternoonCreator: Kaori OzakiLocalization Staff: Daniel Komen (Translator), Risa Cho, Lorina Mapa (Production)Original Release Date: March 10, 2020A…
My Happy Marriage Volume 3 Review
Miyo is kidnapped, and she is once again facing the physical and emotional cruelty from her stepmother and half-sister. Miyo knows that if she agrees to dump Kiyoka,…
Our Fake Marriage Volume 3 Review
With some confusing character motivations and some instances of awkward art, My Fake Marriage Volume 3 continues the series' mediocrity.
Weathering With You Volume 3 Review
The manga of Weathering With You has some warts, but overall, this a worthwhile adaptation of Makoto Shinkai's anime film.
ToHeart Volume 3 Review + Final Thoughts
The finale of this harem-cum-romance manga story!
Manga Review: Robotics;Notes Volume 3
We took a look at Volume 1 and 2... now it's Volume 3's turn! Will it hold well compared to the others?
My Happy Marriage Volume 3 Review
Miyo is kidnapped, and she is once again facing the physical and emotional cruelty from her stepmother and half-sister. Miyo knows that if she agrees to dump Kiyoka,…
Love of Kill Volume 3 Review
There really is a lot to like about Love of Kill, and volume 3 is yet another enjoyable entry in the manga series.