The Poisoned Chocolates Case is a fun trick novel by Anthony Berkeley. The premise is simple: the six members of a club called the Crimes Circle (a bit like the real life Detection Club) decide to investigate a real murder, and each present their theory in turn. Naturally, each member comes to a different conclusion, and each member’s theory seems to disprove the previous member’s. The Poisoned Chocolates Case is a wonderful examination of how shaky detective novel solutions can truly be, in the vein of the Late Queen Problem.The crime the club takes up is, at first glance, straightforward. One day, Eustace Pennefather receives a package of chocolates in the mail at this club, ostensibly as a sample from the maker (but this is later proved to be a fake). Pennefather does not want the chocolates and so gives them to Graham Bendix, another club member, who takes them home to his wife. As you might have guessed from the title, the chocolates are poisoned; Graham eats only a few and grows temporarily ill, but his wife has many more and perishes. The only physical clues are the chocolates, the card with the box, and the packaging.The first section of the novel is dedicated to establishing the facts of the case, and then dives into the successive Crime Circle meetings where each member presents their theory. Each member introduces more and more facts that spin an increasingly complex web, but I remember thinking the information we had for the first member was paltry, yet Berkeley manages to whip up fun and meaty solutions off the bat. There are no solutions that feel trivial or half-baked, so there’s a lot of joy in seeing exactly which direction each member takes the crime in.That’s not to say all solutions are perfect. The third theory is by far the weakest. There they try to find the culprit by giving a list of conditions that they must fulfill until they are able to narrow it down to one person. Which is an entirely reasonable approach (and very [Queensian]), but some of the conditions are downright silly. It makes sense that the culprit would need the scientific knowledge about the poison and the ability to have mailed the parcel, but it’s entirely arbitrary to declare they could not have gone to public school. Considering the book almost reads like a parody of detective stories it feels like this chapter would’ve been a great opportunity to poke fun at “psychological deductions,” but alas, the characters seem to consider this method seriously. (I will admit that the gag for the chapter is fun, though.)I think one way to approach The Poisoned Chocolates Case is as a short story collection, where each story has the same premise but different conclusion. Each answer would be satisfying in its own right (although some more than others), so why not take them all? It’s true that none have fully decisive evidence, but that’s only because each solution needs to segue into the next. If a solution was intended to be true, I’m sure such evidence would have turned up. Each solution presents a mold for a satisfying solution within the context of a detective story, and it’s pure authorial whim that dictates whether truly incontrovertible evidence shows up or not.Having multiple solutions makes The Poisoned Chocolates Case sound a bit similar to multiple-solution books like Mystery Arena, but it plays out relatively different. While Mystery Arena had many more solutions, it was structured as a gameshow where contestants were reading a script, and so could employ narrative tricks as potential solutions. Furthermore, solutions were simply accepted or denied, whereas in The Poisoned Chocolates Case each member must find actual evidence to disregard the previous theory. As a result, The Poisoned Chocolates Case feels more intimately plotted.The other element that sets apart The Poisoned Chocolates Case from other Golden Age books is that Berkeley is a fantastic writer. Even the harshest critique acknowledges the strength of Berkeley’s writing. The vast majority of the novel consists of six people talking in a room, but Berkeley is able to effectively establish and convey the cast’s quirks and personalities, while being humorous and witty to boot. The actual writing is something you often need to simply suffer through with Golden Age detective fiction, but here Berkeley delivers with style and panache.Newer editions of The Poisoned Chocolates Case contain two additional chapters by other writers, each containing a new solution. The saving grace of the first additional chapter, by Christianna Brand, is its brevity. It feels like a lazy, baseless riff off the last theory that doesn’t actually change anything, and Brand’s writing pales when put directly next to Berkeley’s. The second is by Martin Edwards, and is much better. Edwards’ style is much closer to Berkeley’s (whether that was intentional or not), and, while the pivot away from Brand’s solution is awkward and contrived (although I’m not sure how it could not be), and the sixth solution seems to be disregarded for no particular reason, Edwards’ solution provides an answer from yet another completely new angle, which is exactly what I would look for from a Poisoned Chocolates solution.The Poisoned Chocolates Case is an excellently written book built around a fun idea that more than delivers on its promise. A sweet treat for any fan of the genre.
Sep 30, 2025 • Subscribe
More like this
Masters of the Universe: Revelation (Episode 2) – The Poisoned Chalice
Teela has long since given up the hero life and has settled in as an adventurer with her partner, Andra. They’ve just been hired to recover a chalice…
Somali and The Forest Spirit Episode 3 – Poisoned Mushroom
For some reason, the 1000 word or so episode review I wrote for Somali and the Forrest Spirit on Thursday seems to have vanished, all but the feature…
10 Artsy and Creative Chocolates in Japan
From soba infused Venezuelan chocolate to chocolate vinal records and whole edible chocolate bears, here's the best chocolate in Japan.
Ron Kamonohashi: Deranged Detective Episode 10 Review – The Poisoned Latte
Totomaru gains a fangirl!
Case 68 – The Case Closedys
We managed to sneak in one last episode before the end of 2020. We are joined by VLord and Sakaki to go over the Wedding Murder Case. This…
The Mummy Case
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
Teleport Them Chocolates: Ogiue Maniax Status Update for February 2021
We are on the other side of a terrifying four years, and I am glad to be here with you. Though we don’t know what the future holds,…
Adachi to Shimamura – Episode 8 – Quest for Valentines Day Chocolates
Episode impressions of Adachi to Shimamura Episode 8 as Valentine’s Day nears, Adachi wonders what kind of chocolates to give as she figures out her strategy.
The Yufuin Murder Case
湯布院殺人事件 (Yufuin satsujinjiken, The Yufuin Murder Case , 1994) is a not very interesting mystery by UCHIDA Yasuo (内田康夫). The main characters ...
The Ice-Cold Case
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
Case 8 – Case Hyphen Closed
We now begin our venture into the anime world by going over the first case that was released on Crunchyroll, The Tragedy of the Red Woman. We go…
The Case of the Photo Finish
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
The Case of the Photo Finish
detective fiction, 推理小説、games,
The Case of the Constant Suicides
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
The Case of the Floating Crime
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
The Case of the Silver Bullet
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
The Case of the Seven Bells
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
The Case of the Creative Crime
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
Case 1 – The Hard Sell
Our first episode of the podcast is up, kind of. On the 71st episode of the SSAA Podcast, the show premiered along with our other affiliate podcast, Just…
Case 72 – The Dolphin Curse
We are joined by Matt of OverMangaCast to go over one of the longer cases we’ve had as we cover most of Volume 23 with The Cruise Ship…
The Peculiar Case of Chuunibyou
So, recently, I’ve been watching some sports anime.
The Curious Case of Otomate
Otomate is, like you would expect from a company with “otome” in the title, oriented to make stuff for women…but that’s obviously not the end of the story.…
Case 3 – Off The Radar
Sorry for the delay everyone but now we are back and we are not alone. Our friends from the AniManga Podcast, Jammer and Dominic, are going to be…
Case 83 – That’s The Tea
Taking a small break from the manga to watch a young man make spaghetti and clean his car. We are joined by Brenda of Secret Histories of Nerd…
Case 7 – Cracking The Code
We finally reach the end of Volume 4 of the manga. We go over the Code Sheet Case as we cover Files 36-39 of the manga. Download here
Cracking the Case: Pearl Pureheart
Her soprano singing is completely uncredited. The female voice artist remains a mystery to this day.
The Case Study of Vanitas
The Case Study of Vanitas is currently streaming on Funimation....
The Glass Case & Screaming Heart
Interesting post name right? You’ll see. There is a Naruto ending song that I identify very much with. It’s ending number 20, called, “By My Side” by Hemenway.…
Case 51 – The Incredible Ran
After giving everyone time to be able to listen to the mammoth sized 50th episode, we have come back to continue going through volume 17 of the Case…
Case Closed: Zero the Enforcer
I know I just reviewed a Case Closed/Detective Conan movie, but I told you guys I am a super fan after all. I eat this stuff up. This…
The Infuriating Case of Engrish
Even if the industry can be content with it, I won't. I endured both Engrish and bad dubs for decades. One improved, the other did not.
![Featured image for The Case Study of Vanitas: Second Season PV [Case Study of Vanitas]](https://cdn.aniblogtracker.com/live/20211229/1640804915.28162.55506.jpg)
The Case Study of Vanitas: Second Season PV [Case Study of Vanitas]
I haven’t forgotten the second season of the Case Study of Vanitas is airing next season and I’m looking forward to it enough that I’ve abstained from looking…
The Case of the Bland Otome Heroine
Why are otome game heroines such blank slates?
Case Closed: The Crimson Love Letter
Case Closed is a favorite TV series of mine. I have been a major fan ever since Adult Swim played this one on tv way back in the…
The Curious Case of Interspecies reviewers
Just to be straight with all of you, this isn’t going to be a post on Interspecies Reviewers. I have not watched the show. I wanted to but…
The Tragic Case of Soul Eater
Soul Eater was undeniably great and I still recommend it if you can stick around through its awkward adolescence.
Case 112 – Twitter Marks The Spot
Returning guest Darren Vogt helps us decipher PlayStation controller icons on the last case of Volume 33 (chapters 338-340) with The Escalator Message Case. This episode was released…
Case 75 – Shinichi The Door Open
We have an episode full of retcons and plot points here on this episode of One Podcast Prevails. We are joined by our friend Sakaki to go over…
The Case Study of Vanitas (1)
Author & Artist Jun MochizukiReleased December 2016 by Yen PressTranslation: Taylor EngelEditor(s): unlistedGenre: Action, Mystery, Drama
Case 74 – The Sock Hop Mystery
We are joined by Destiny of the Getting Animated Podcast as we go over the next case of Volume 24, The Blackout Murder Case. This episode was released…
The Silver Case / シルバー事件
The Silver Case takes place in 1999 in the (fictional) 24th Ward of Tokyo , where the murderer Kamui Uehara committed the titular Silver Ca...
The Case for Steven Universe - Prelude
Install Raid for Free ✅ IOS/ANDROID/PC: https://pl.go-ga.me/fhr9zcmh and get a special starter pack with an Epic champion ⚡️Drake⚡️ Available only for new players 🎃 Take part in the…
Case 69 – The Big Choo Choo
We finally make our return for 2021! Nice! We continue through Volume 22 of Case Closed by going over the North Star Murder Case. This episode was release…
The Centennial Case: A Shijima Story
Are you a murder mystery buff? Then The Centennial Case: A Shijima Story should go on your “to-play” list immediately.
Case 4 – Picking Up The Pieces
As we said before, the game is far from over. After a long hiatus, One Podcast Prevails returns with some old guests from the Animanga Podcast to talk…
“Case of the Gloomy Gondolier” (1963)
The Sam Bassett cartoons are both bizarre and fascinating - and pretty hard to find prints of.
Case 6 – The Hype Train Explodes
Yes, we have already made a new episode. We have already done better than the last three years . On this episode, we go over the Shinkansen Bomb…
The Curious Case of Okitegami Kyouko
From now on, you will live as Okitegami Kyouko — a detective.
The Case Files of Jeweler Richard
No post summary was provided.
Case 27 – FLICK
We end this year with murder! On our last episode of 2016, we finish volume 9 of the Case Closed manga as we cover the Heiress Murder Case.…