"Tell me, Leonard," he said. "Has it ever occurred to you that one day wars will be fought with brains?"Leonard picked up his coffee cup. "Oh dear. Won’t that be rather messy?" he said."The Fifth Elephant" It was only after buying today's book I realized I basically own no other books by the same publisher (Gentosha)...The handsome Hamon Kyousuke is a medium who's been attracting a lot of attention lately and the television screenwriter Kagitani Takashi has organized a small seance at the house of an art collector with Hamon. Other guests include art-related people as well as three editors working for a magazine, including Tomoe and Makabe, the latter having a crush on Tomoe, but unable to propose due to an inherited debt. During the seance, Hamon is challenged on his psychic powers, and he defiantly announces he can use his powers to remotely kill someone. He asks for anyone to name someone they want to have killed, and while initially nobody dares to utter a name, Tomoe and Makabe's superior eventually names an artist, because he stood him and Makabe up earlier this day despite having an appointment. Hamon then says he will take control of the artist's body, forcing himself to commit suicide. While they initially don't believe Hamon, doubt starts to creep in so they drive by the artist's house to check up on him, only to find all the furniture being placed outside the house. They have to move stuff around, only to find the door locked from the inside. And inside the locked house, they find the artist dead, hanging from the ceiling as announced by Hamon! Unable to believe Hamon truly has powers, murder is suspected by those involved in the seance, including the detective Senoo Yuuji, but how did Hamon commit this locked room murder, and why was everything placed outside? When later Hamon once again announces a remote murder and another body is found, people start to think Hamon really has the power to control people and make them commit suicide, but Senoo is not convinced and assisted by Makabe, he uncovers the truth in Asukabe Katsunori's Leonardo no Chinmoku ("The Silence of Leonardo", 2004).Leonardo no Chinmoku was originally released in 2004, but only got its pocket re-release in 2025, after the amazing revival of interest in Asukabe's work, that was set in motion after the bookshops Shosen and Horindo put out limited facsimile releases of his out-of-print works: the facsimile release Datenshi Goumonkei ("Torture of the Fallen Angels" 2008) in particular was a notable event, gathering a lot of attention. Since then, publishers have been re-releasing a lot of Asukabe's books from their catalogues that had previously been out-of-print for over a decade, like Lamia Gyakusatsu ("Lamia Massacre"). Leonardo no Chinmoku is another of these "hey, it's a bit late but perhaps we should put out a pocket" release.The story revolves around a problem often see in other psychic/seance-themed mysteries: a psychic correctly announcing something will happen, with the mystery focusing on how they could've known that: of course the psychic in question in this case has an alibi for the death, meaning they themselves couldn't have known about the murder because they committed the murder (or did they, and did they fake their alibis in some way?) In this case, we also have the added mystery of the locked room, and the question of why all the furniture was placed outside. I have to admit I wasn't completely convinced by this murder. A lot of the mechanics surrounding the solution of this mystery revolve around coincidence, with certain events and people just happen to be timing up perfectly by sheer luck. The solution behind how the locked room situation was created too was simple, while the answer to why all the furniture was outside feels underdeveloped: while it touches upon a greater theme and the book does try to present as something big, I don't feel this whydunnit was developed properly as of now: it needed more set-up to give you that "Aha!" feeling, because as it is now, you kinda get what they were going for, but it's not completely convincing and even worse, it's basically unguessable from a fair-play mystery point of view. It'a s shame, because this is when the book is supposed to be most strongly connected to the Leonardo from the title Leonardo no Chinmoku, who is of course Leonardo da Vinci. Art is an important motif throughout most, if not all of Asukabe's books (he even made original paintings for his debut novel!), but I'd say that in this book, art might be of the least importance of all the Asukabe's books I have read until now. Whereas the first death predicted by Hamon was found in an 'inside-out' house (furniture found outside), the second victim 'killed remotely' by Hamon is lying found 'upside-down' next to a road, continuing the topsy-turvy theme. While this murder also depends on coincidence up to some degree, I like the build-up of this murder a lot more: the clewing is better, being more connected to other plotlines of the book and with a more even distribution of the clues across the whole book, and I think the way it's connected to the first murder works well too. In hindsight, it's actually funny how much more integrated this murder is to the rest of the book compared to the first locked room murder. I think basically all of the most interesting elements of Leonardo no Chinmoku's narrative revolve around this second death, rather than the first death, even if the actual scene of the first seance is better.Leonardo no Chinmoku is the most straightforward mystery novel I have read by Asukabe until now, and it's also perhaps my least favorite. While the plot depends a bit too much on coincidence and I don't really think the whydunnit behind the first murder works well, the overall plot is an adequately constructed mystery, with especially the plotlines pertaining to the second half being well-planned. But on the other hand, I can't deny missing some of the insaneness I have seen in other works by Asukabe and while I am not very versed, nor interested in art in general, I do feel the general lack in discussion on art here hurts the book a bit. It's great the book's easily available again now and mind you, this is not a bad mystery novel by any means, but I wouldn't pick this as my first Asukabe to read.Original Japanese title(s): 飛鳥部勝則『レオナルドの沈黙』
8 days ago • Subscribe
More like this
A Case of Immunity
detective fiction, 推理小説、games, mystery, murder, locked room, Japanese, translations,
Case 49 – Son Of A Beach
We have returned to read some awkward matchmaking and enjoy a day at the beach in the middle of winter as we go over the Scuba Diving Case.…
Tree Spirits Grass Spirits
Tree Spirits Grass Spirits collects twenty-one autobiographical stories about plants by the celebrated Japanese-American poet Hiromi Ito. As translator Jon L Pitt explains in the preface, these sto…
Romance of the Imperial Capital Kotogami: A Tale of Living Alongside Spirits
By Yamori Mitikusa and Tokihito Saiga. Released in Japan as “Teito Kotogami Romantan Kinrou Otome to Oshikake Juusha” by Kotonoha Bunko. Released in North America by Cross Infinite…
Romance of the Imperial Capital Kotogami: A Tale of Living Alongside Spirits
Information for the series Romance of the Imperial Capital Kotogami: A Tale of Living Alongside Spirits. The official English release is from Cross Infinite World.
Case 80 – Take A Bite Out Of Crime
We continue our readthrough of the Desperate Revival arc by going over the School Play Murder Case with the hosts of the Manga Mavericks podcast, LumRanmaYasha and McGruff…
Case Study of Vanitas Is A Crazy Anime
Anime Name: Case Study of Vanitas ヴァニタスの手記カルテ Vanitasu no Karute Where to Watch: Crunchy Roll There once lived a vampire known as Vanitas, hated by his own kind for being born…
Bonded Spirits
This novel series felt really haphazardly put together. The plot is centered around a protagonist getting transported into a world with monster girls who he bonds with in…
Summit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! #07 — Song of the Spirits
Please stop rapping. Impressions: Another attempt at a horror parody, but more on the level of Scooby Doo this time than the previous one's more modern, existential…
Case 23 – Pitching A Tent
We start having strange feelings and learn geography on this episode of One Podcast Prevails. On this episode, continue through volume eight of the Detective Conan/Case Closed manga…
Case 12 – Pulling A Mouri
We got more manga to talk about as we go through the next case in volume five, Karaoke Box Murder Case. Download here Show Notes “Sunflowers of Inferno”…
Case 113 – A Crossover Episode
The remaining co-host of the Ass Backwards Anime Podcast finally appears on One Podcast Prevails as we are joined by Foxy to talk about the Lupin III vs.…
A Case study of the Reitaisai 19 Fumo incident
I wasn’t around for the previous sales on AmiAmi EN but I heard the horror stories; site crashing constantly, cart not saving items, pages not loading, everything sold…
A Review of Lord El-Melloi II’s Case Files
Worldbuilding is something I get unusually excited about when it is done a certain way. I’ve often ranted about shows like Kekkai Sensen, which depict the supernatural chaos,…
The Case Study of Vanitas ep.15 – Bird of a Wire
The Case Study of Vanitas is shaping up to be one of my favourite shows of the season. It's silly and stylish and just a little bloody.
The Case Study of Vanitas ep.10 – Birds of a Feather
The Case Study of Vanitas is shaping up to be one of my favourite shows of the season. It's silly and stylish and just a little bloody.
The Case Study of Vanitas ep.16 – Birds of a Feather
The Case Study of Vanitas continues to be one of my favourite shows of the season. It's silly and stylish and just a little bloody.
Malevolent Spirits #23 — Return of the Flashback
Why are we sad about those two dying again? Or living for that matter. Impressions: Why exactly are we getting a big emotional melodramatic sequence for these…
Winter’s Wish Spirits of Edo Kinji Walkthrough
Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo Kinji Walkthrough: Guide to help you full clear Kinji's route in the otome Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo
Winter’s Wish Spirits of Edo Yoichi Walkthrough
Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo Yoichi Walkthrough: Guide to help you full clear Yoichi's route in the otome Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo
Winter’s Wish: Spirits of Edo Otome Review
Winter’s Wish: Spirits of Edo is a supernatural historical otome game developed by Otomate and published by Aksys Games for the Nintendo Switch. A secret organization recruits a…
Winter’s Wish Spirits of Edo Ohtaro Walkthrough
Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo Ohtaro Walkthrough: Guide to help you full clear Ohtaro's route in the otome Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo
Malevolent Spirits: Mononogatari
By: Onigunsou Disclaimer: This review is based on volumes 1-2 (chapter 1-11) Summary: There are powerful beings whose spirits dwell within old objects: tsukumogami. Hyoma is a young…
Only Bad Spirits?
A friend of mine lent me several volumes of Mieruko-chan. I have not watched the 2021 anime, so my perspective on it is based on the manga. Miko…
Spirits & Cat Ears
By: Miyuki Nakayama Disclaimer: This review is based on volumes 1 (chapter 1-4) Summary: Neneko Iizuna is a shy girl with a secret: cat ears. Embarrassed over her…
Aksys Games Summons a Card Set for Winter’s Wish: Spirits of Edo
Called a monster and banished from her village, Suzuno finds herself in the midst of a supernatural battle against evil Aksys Games revealed the exclusive set of seven…
Arabashiri – Sake Spirits with Soul in a Manga
I’m back on my usual shenanigans with another manga that I picked up purely due to my own preferences that only a select few will care about. Being…
Malevolent Spirits #02 — A Little Harmless Attempted Murder
Who among us hasn't tried to kill someone checking to see if we're not murderous? Impressions: This would be so much more tolerable if the animation during…
![Featured image for The Case Study of Vanitas: Second Season PV [Case Study of Vanitas]](https://cdn.aniblogtracker.com/live/20211229/1640804915.28162.55506.jpg)
The Case Study of Vanitas: Second Season PV [Case Study of Vanitas]
I haven’t forgotten the second season of the Case Study of Vanitas is airing next season and I’m looking forward to it enough that I’ve abstained from looking…
What’s in a Detective Conan (Case Closed) Weiss Schwarz Blau Case?
So what comes inside a Weiss Schwarz Blau case? My name is Billy, but I go by “Otaku Sinh” or “otakusinh” on various platforms. Like my other anime…
The Case Study of Vanitas ep.17 – A Noble Woman
The Case Study of Vanitas continues to be one of my favourite shows of the season. It's silly and stylish and just a little bloody.
The Case Study of Vanitas ep.3 – What A Jerk
The Case Study of Vanitas just started and I'm already very excited about this new season. I sure hope it can keep this momentum.
Case 86 – Statue of Limitations
Brenda brought back our third chair so now we can go back to talking about the next case of Volume 27 of the Case Closed manga, Sato’s Father…
The Peculiar Case of Chuunibyou
So, recently, I’ve been watching some sports anime.
The Curious Case of Otomate
Otomate is, like you would expect from a company with “otome” in the title, oriented to make stuff for women…but that’s obviously not the end of the story.…
The Case Study of Vanitas
The Case Study of Vanitas is currently streaming on Funimation....
The Infuriating Case of Engrish
Even if the industry can be content with it, I won't. I endured both Engrish and bad dubs for decades. One improved, the other did not.
Case 85 – Doing A Die Hard
Our rotating third chair, Brenda, returns to talk about more Detective Conan anime. This time we talk about a couple of towers as we go over Movie 5,…
Case 46 – Don’t Catch A Cold
Our second episode during the holiday break is here. Celebrate with the Detective Boys as we go over the School Mystery Case. This episode was release earlier on…
Case 17 – Lion In A Tank
Our first case of 2016! We are back on the manga and going over the first proper case of volume 6, The Antique Collector Murder Case. Let’s go!…
The Centennial Case: A Shijima Story
Are you a murder mystery buff? Then The Centennial Case: A Shijima Story should go on your “to-play” list immediately.
A Case of Characters – A Review of Kubikiri Cycle: Aoiro Savant to Zaregototsukai (2016-2017)
“Just as the opposite of love is not indifference… The opposite of hope is not despair. Apathy so strong that nothing matters anymore – that’s the opposite of…
Winter’s Wish Spirits of Edo Kunitaka Tojo Walkthrough
Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo Kunitaka Walkthrough: Guide to help you full clear Kunitaka's route in the otome Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo
Winter’s Wish Spirits of Edo Genjuro Kuga Walkthrough
Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo Genjuro Kuga Walkthrough: Guide to help you full clear Genjuro's route in the otome Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo
Malevolent Spirits #06 — Twenty More Minutes of Exposition
Pacing. What is it? Impressions: What an absolutely pointless and horrible episode. After last week's explanation that Botan is the star child, here's a second episode explaining…
Winter’s Wish Spirits of Edo Tomonari Takamura Walkthrough
Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo Tomonari Walkthrough: Guide to help you full clear Tomonari's route in the otome Winter's Wish Spirits of Edo
OtakuGeneration (Show #387) Origin: Spirits of the Past
Shownotes :: (show 387) :: () :: () :: () :: () With Origin: Spirits of the Past, recorded live November 7th, 2012. This week we watched Origin "Spirits…
Bakemonogatari, Berserk, Cluster Edge, Golden Boy, Maria Watches Over Us
Case 68 – The Case Closedys
We managed to sneak in one last episode before the end of 2020. We are joined by VLord and Sakaki to go over the Wedding Murder Case. This…
Case 8 – Case Hyphen Closed
We now begin our venture into the anime world by going over the first case that was released on Crunchyroll, The Tragedy of the Red Woman. We go…